As Seen in Republic Report Q4 2024
Land can be an excellent means of transferring wealth to future generations. In the next ten years, Texas will likely see the biggest shift of land ownership from one generation to the next. Inheriting a ranch can be a blessing or a burden. It depends on how the family passes it down and the heirs’ goals. At Republic Ranches, we’ve helped many clients buy legacy ranches, sell land they’ve inherited, and navigate the complexities of shared family ownership. As a ranch is passed down through generations, the heirs’ desires often diverge, leading to friction if family members fail to communicate effectively or if the estate plan is too restrictive. The estate planning landscape is intricate and continuously evolving. We highlight key elements of estate planning that, as real estate professionals, we believe can turn inheriting a ranch into a blessing rather than a burden for all parties.
As we begin this series, one of the most important actions a family can take is to have open discussions about what each beneficiary wants regarding the ranch asset. Furthermore, what are the wishes of the patriarch upon their passing? Understanding everyone’s preferences will help the family set up the estate for a smooth transition and maximize tax benefits that fit their specific plan when the ranch is passed down. When we talked to estate attorneys while preparing for this series, we found that a major obstacle for families is having open and honest conversations when they sit down together. Here’s an example of what can happen if wishes do not align. The patriarch may wish to prevent the sale of the ranch and could structure the estate to make it difficult for the beneficiaries to sell their individual interests. The patriarch has good intentions, thinking their wishes will keep the ranch and family together across generations. As the ranch passes from one generation to the next, it may lead to conflicts among the beneficiaries. Factors such as the cost of maintenance compared to individual usage, the rising value of the land, and differing opinions on capital can drive them apart. A beneficiary might want to sell their share, causing family conflict. This could lead to a lawsuit for dividing assets, as per Texas law (Tex. Prop. Code § 23A.007). The will ties beneficiaries together and lacks conflict resolution, often leading to prolonged disputes. In contrast, an upfront agreement could have considered the beneficiaries’ wishes by offering a buy-out option or dividing their inheritance from different assets that others may not value as emotionally, such as special bequests of real estate or equalizing amounts in cash, company shares, or other physical assets. We can all agree that family is more valuable than land. Regularly having these essential and sometimes difficult conversations can prevent years, if not decades, of disputes.
Several exit strategies include non-pro rata estate division, buy-sell provision, Rights of First Refusal (ROFR), buyouts, and the ability to partition. For future real estate sales, if financially feasible, consider advantageous options like non-pro rata estate division, buy-sell options, or buyout provisions. These arrangements let beneficiaries manage the assets they prefer, which minimizes the risk of lowering the ranch’s value for future resale. We believe that partitioning can be a good way to resolve conflicts, but it can be very tricky. Emotions often influence these splits. For instance, a beneficiary may be emotionally attached to the hacienda and willing to sacrifice road frontage in order to gain access to the home and land they want, which could lead to a negative feature that affects the value of one or all of the resulting partitions. Several factors should be considered when dividing land. These include whether there is enough road frontage to split it equally, and if there are any additional features that could complicate a fair division, such as live water, floodplains, upward improvements, and the locations of electricity, water, oil, and gas activity, as well as existing easements. Some estate plans may decide to partition during their lifetime for tax purposes or may include a clause about partitioning upon death. If the property is divided after someone dies, it’s a good idea to make sure the beneficiaries don’t have any objections to the proposed division beforehand. You should also talk to a knowledgeable land broker to understand how splitting the property in the way the family wants will affect its market value when it’s time to sell. Additionally, while a ROFR might appear to be a reasonable solution in estate planning, it can obstruct the transfer of a beneficiary’s interest if other beneficiaries lack the funds to acquire it. Typically, it requires a patient buyer willing to risk losing the opportunity since the First Right may be exercised. In our experience, Right of First Refusal can discourage buyers and limit the market, which reduces competition and negatively affects value. Additionally, the ROFR ambiguity can cause conflicts, particularly regarding how and when offers were communicated, and whether the response time met the ROFR provisions. While we don’t particularly favor them in the real estate sales world, we recognize that it might be the best compromise to allow the other beneficiaries to explore ways to secure the necessary capital, knowing they are likely paying a fair market value based on the acceptable offer to maintain the integrity of the ranch.
Navigating the estate planning landscape can be complex and daunting for families. As land professionals, we have witnessed a variety of strategies that we put into action. Families have counted on us to help them decide how to handle inherited land. Through our research in this series, one thing is clear: we are not experts in estate planning or taxation. It was enlightening—and, dare I say, mind-blowing to learn about the innovative tax and transfer strategies available based on family assets and dynamics. This series aims to give you talking points for your next family gathering. It should also help you understand the benefits and challenges of proper and improper planning in our field. At Republic Ranches, the family holds greater significance than land. Our utmost desire is to help clients navigate challenging ownership transitions while preserving strong family bonds and a lasting legacy.
Read the full Republic Report here.